Menu
  • Home
  • About
    • Contact
      • Subscribe
      • Close
    • Close
  • In Season
    • Basketball
    • MMA
    • Running
    • Soccer
    • Close
  • Pro
  • Olympics
  • College
  • High School
  • Youth
  • Coaching
  • Business
  • Title IX
  • Entertainment
  • Inspiration

Women Talk Sports

Women's Sports News and Commentary

You are here: Home / Sports / From the archives: Baseball and the Romantics

August 4, 2014 By Wendy Parker's Extracurriculars Leave a Comment

From the archives: Baseball and the Romantics

While I’m taking a summer break from the blog, I’m reposting and updating selected links from the archive.

* * * * * * * *

With another Baseball Hall of Fame Class having been inducted into Cooperstown, I thought I’d dig into the XCs vault and link to a post from January 2013, “Baseball’s Dwindling Romantics,” about Hall of Fame voting and steroids.

The new development coming out of the most recent festivities is that the Baseball Writers Association of America has reduced the time for newly-retired candidates to remain on the eligible list from 15 to 10 years. The HOF and writers explicitly deny the move was made given the long list of eligibles from the so-called steroids era.

But the new rule means that Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens have only eight years remaining to reach the 75 percent threshold of a plurality of votes from sportswriters, instead of 13. Both have received fewer than 40 percent in each of their first two years of eligibility, and their second-year percentage dropped slightly. The Romantics are still deeply entrenched among establishment writers, and clearly have the upper hand here.

Blood SportAlso new is the publication of”Blood Sport,” which details Major League Baseball’s investigation of the Biogenesis lab. The book was written by Tom Elfrink and Gus Garcia-Roberts of the Miami New Times, which broke a good deal of the story that eventually led to the current season-long suspension of Alex Rodriguez.

Dave Sheinin of The Washington Post writes in a review that “there is a tangible sense of steroids fatigue among baseball observers.” The most useful material in “Blood Sport,” he says, doesn’t come along until there are 100 pages left.

There’s a clear understanding among non-Romantics, especially a new wave of baseball writers skeptical of absolutist pontificating, about the role and history of steroids in a sport that was the last to bring down the hammer. As I wrote last January:

“The black-and-white persistence of the Romantics is fading away, but not because of any perceived moral relativism by a younger generation of writers or players who may shrug their shoulders at ‘juicing.’ There is a heavy dose of realism and probity that is entering the discussion, a strong counter to those who wish to oversimplify.”

The A-Rod suspension may have pleased the Romantics. But the actions of Bud Selig’s henchmen and the commissioner himself, in rendering a purely arbitrary punishment, should be more worrisome than anything ballplayers ever injected into their blood streams.

Especially when the now-retiring Selig sat on his hands for years, fully aware of what was transpiring in his domain.

Powered by Sidelines

Share this:

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Tumblr

Related

Filed Under: Sports, Baseball, Books, Media

What’s Popular:

  • Must-See Women's Skateboarding Site From Jenna Selby
  • Dooney & Bourke Launches Collegiate Handbag Line for 15 Schools
  • Hoopism: Some oddities in the last night of games before break
    Hoopism: Some oddities in the last night of games before break
  • MMA Weekend Results - Parker Upsets Gutierrez; Nakamoto Defends Muay Thai title
  • A Dream Coming True For This 6 Year Old Skater

Speak up! Leave a Comment: Cancel reply

Women’s Sports News

Serena Williams Honored as Sports Illustrated’s Sportsperson of the Year

December 14, 2015 5:41 pm

Rebecca Hart is awarded a Women’s Sports Foundation Travel & Training Grant

December 3, 2015 9:04 pm

BR: Holly Holm’s Violent KO of Ronda Rousey Puts Division Front and Center

November 16, 2015 1:04 am

Laurel J. Richie To Depart WNBA

November 4, 2015 10:41 pm

Shannon Boxx bids farewell as USWNT looks ahead to Rio with new players

October 23, 2015 10:51 pm

Subscribe to our e-Newsletter

We'll send you the best headlines from women's sports, no more than once a week, and we'll never share your information with third parties.

Ashley Caldwell nails the triple, wins Freestyle Aerials at World Cup

The Latest in Women’s Sports:

Hoopism: Some oddities in the last night of games before break

December 24, 2015 By Sue Favor Leave a Comment

A Powerful Ritual for the New Year

December 23, 2015 By Erica Quam Leave a Comment

Hey, Leave Ballerinas Out Of It

December 22, 2015 By GladiatHers 1 Comment

Hoopism: Beyond the Games

December 21, 2015 By Sue Favor Leave a Comment

C&R: Stanford Crushed Cornell

December 20, 2015 By C and R's Stanford Women's Basketball Blog Leave a Comment

Pretty Tough

Home · Legal · Contact · Copyright Women Talk Sports, LLC© 2015 · Log in

Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.