Thanks for the tip SkiMama. I just had a look at that site, it is great, packed with info. Thanks ...more
posted 07/14/11 at 6:34am
on Checking in on women's rugby sites
posted by One Sport Voice
Thursday, January 14, 2010 at 5:43pm EST
Dr. Nicole M. LaVoi: This blog reflects my critical eye and voice on all things sport. I am a critical thinker, scholar, and researcher in girls & women in sport, youth sport, and coach & sport parent education.
Support women's sports and SHARE this story with your friends!
In the last week Austrian coaches claimed downhill skier and USA Olympian (and fellow Minnesotan!) Lindsay Vonn was heavy, which they said gives her a competitive advantage. Really? Are you sure she isn’t one of the best skiers because she is an amazing athlete who trains hard?
I was called by local WCCO TV reporter Heather Brown to comment on this issue. I didn’t know where to start, there were just so many angles of this story. Here are my thoughts:
1. From a sport psychology perspective, the Austrian coaches could of purposely leaked the comment to the media to distract Vonn’s attention away from optimal performance. That appears to have backfired, as Vonn responded as a mentally tough athlete would by choosing not to comment much and use it for fuel to further motivate her. Vonn’s response was that of a champion. She couldn’t control what was said, but the did control how she responded. Point Vonn!
2. From a sport media perspective, the comment about Vonn’s weight is yet another example of how the focus on female athlete’s appearance seems to be more important than her performance. Serena Williams is constantly being criticized for being “too big and muscular” and people seem confused as to how a woman so “big” can be so good. Yes we do hear comments about male athlete’s bodies, but it is rarely about appearance…it is about strength, power, speed. I doubt we will hear an Austrian coach discuss Bode Miller’s weight. When a female athlete dominates her sport and her body doesn’t conform to the traditional feminine norm, she comes under surveillance. Think of South African sprinter Caster Semenya from this summer.
The Vonn comment is a bit unique because the coach said her “extra weight” gives her a competitive advantage. It reminded me of similar comments made about Danica Patrick, when opponents claimed she had a unfair competitive advantage because she weighed less than the males drivers. The point is, comments about a female athlete’s weight is a way to minimize her performances, and “explain” why she excels rather than attributing winning to athleticism.
3. Lastly, the weight comment conveys to young girls and female athletes that emphasis is placed on what the body looks like, than what it can do. Constant media messages like the Vonn comment socializes girls and women into becoming obsessed on physical appearance, rather than on health, well-being, and optimal performance.
As head into the Vancouver Olympics keep a close eye on how the media constructs Lindsey Vonn as the poster girl for the team.
Support women's sports and SHARE this story with your friends!
MOST POPULAR POSTS
posted by From A Left Wing
06/27/11 at 8:06pm
posted by C and R's Stanford Women's Basketball Blog
07/11/11 at 11:08am
posted by margiepritchard
07/13/11 at 8:58am
posted by Alison M. Starnes Blog
07/08/11 at 10:27am
posted by All White Kit
09/15/10 at 3:21pm
posted by All White Kit
06/08/11 at 1:39am
posted by All White Kit
09/12/10 at 1:57pm
posted by Women Undefined
07/31/10 at 10:26pm
posted by Wombat Sports
07/09/11 at 9:48am
posted by MsAkiba
10/11/09 at 2:40pm
LATEST WTS POSTS
posted by Swish Appeal
Thu at 2:40pm
posted by HoopFeed.com
Thu at 1:04pm
posted by Ask Lauren Fleshman
Thu at 1:03pm
posted by Jayda Evans: Womens Hoops Blog
Thu at 12:51pm
posted by From A Left Wing
Thu at 12:47pm
posted by They're Playing Basketball
Thu at 12:41pm
posted by They're Playing Basketball
Thu at 12:37pm
posted by Alison M. Starnes Blog
Thu at 12:35pm
posted by MMARising.com
Thu at 12:34pm
posted by Soccer Science
Thu at 12:23pm
No one has commented on this yet. Be the first!