Quantcast

Little League World Series broadcasts inequality

posted by Fair Game News
Saturday, August 20, 2011 at 3:36pm EDT

Seeking equality on -- and off -- the field. The strong connection between organized athletics and power (political, economic, social) means sports have consequences far beyond the game. FairGameNews.com aims to challenge sex-stereotyped assumptions and practices that dominate sports -- and recognize that sports can be a tool for seeking equal treatment and fair play.

Support women's sports and SHARE this story with your friends!

By Laura Pappano

If it’s late August, it must be Little League World Series time – and our annual reminder of why Title IX is needed, but not enough.

The disparities in treatment, support, and attention for male and female athletes begins early, and nowhere is it more obvious than in Little League.

Just consider the annual baseball and softball World Series playoff events. The Little League Softball World Series, which just wrapped up, featured 27 games, with semi-finals and the championship aired on ESPN2. That’s THREE games.

Now multiply that by 11 and you’ll have the number of Little League Baseball World Series games broadcast – and many on ESPN HD (for those keeping track, that’s every single game played in the series).

Oh, and the August 27 finals are on CBS in –– HD.

Nearly every element of these two marquis events reveals institutional and cultural sexism (yes, girls are allowed to play Little League Baseball but it is rare and in many places are discouraged from doing so). One has only to glance at the websites (here and here) for the two World Series events to spot vastly different levels of support.

Curious about the players? The Little League Softball World Series site features team photos. The Little League Baseball World Series site lets you click down to individual players – and watch video of them in action. The level of information (want souvenir tickets?) and polish between the two sites is absurdly disparate.

This is not meant as a criticism of the softball effort (May we remember that these are 12-year-olds?), but of the blatant institutional gap. The matter is, frankly, puzzling. Why doesn’t Little League at least try – a little?

Granted, right there in the media guide, the organizational timeline points out that in 1972 after the passage of Title IX that, “Little League resists the entry of girls into the program.” In 1974, the organization decides “to allow participation by girls” (after a New Jersey Court ordered them to), but immediately creates Little League Softball – which helps to keep girls from joining baseball.

Many years have passed, but not enough has changed.

As the girls and boys of summer play out their Little League World Series dreams — dreams structured by an organization that portrays itself as a gift to youth development – isn’t it time to make gender fairness a goal?

It would be as important for the boys as it would be for the girls.


http://www.softballworldseries.com/schedule.htm

Support women's sports and SHARE this story with your friends!


Filed Under:  

View Original Post at fairgamenews.com

View FGN's Full Profile

There are 2 comments on this post. Join the discussion!

McCarter.Nathan says:

A couple of issues I feel that should be mentioned:

1. The Little League World Series has a long history, and thus has a much larger and dedicated fanbase. The Softball World Series does not. It will continue to grow and having ESPN2 air the semi's and finals is a step in the right direction.

2. ESPN will respond to ratings. They aren't being discriminatory and they have no obligation to air things equally. This would be the same in arguing that major media outlets should be obligated to air the women's tackle football league in the same capacity that they do the NFL. Which, I'm sorry, is just a blatantly poor way to look at it. I was very excited when I saw the Softball games hit ESPN, but the LLWS has been a staple on television for decades and has gained an incredible following and big ratings. Those big ratings over the years have led to more games and larger platforms. Overtime if the Softball side grows it will do the same.

ESPN isn't going to discriminate but they are going to air what will draw the most viewers, and subsequent advertisers, to their network. And there is nothing wrong with that.

And the same goes for the websites. I agree that more should be placed on to the softball side, but currently the hits for the site are vastly in favor of the LLWS. And as they draw in more money I'm sure they have spent more of their resources in optimizing that site. However, I think they should invest a little more time and effort in to making that more equal - I'll definitely agree to that. But in its totality Little League International is in a tough spot. They don't have deep pockets and rely on regional offices. The Midwest regional office has two administrative members, two maintenance workers and a secretary for over 1,000 little leagues in multiple states. And this is typical for other regional offices. Their dollar is stretched fairly thin.

In the end, I agree that there should be an equal footing on the website. It should be uniform across the board (in design and information - baseball will have more video access for the time being though). But ESPN and other media outlets should not be demonized for doing their job and basing their programming on ratings as that translates to the health of their business. I commend ESPN for showing dedication to softball as a whole - airing USA Softball games, signing a SEC contract and frequently airing their games and now the incremental addition of the LLWS of Softball. It'll take time but over the last five years we have seen substantial growth for softball through ESPN.

Saturday, August 20, 2011 at 3:51pm EDT

womentalksports says:

Is televising youth sports a bit exploitive? Regardless of whether it's baseball or softball, the programming stars 11 and 12 year old kids who may not be ready for the spotlight. LLWS Home Run or Foul

Friday, August 26, 2011 at 12:44am EDT

Leave Your Comment:  Read our comment policy

  |  

Today on the Women's Sports Calendar:

NCAA DI Field Hockey Championships
Nov 16 - 18: Powhatan Sports Complex
NCAA DI Cross Country Championship
November 17: E.P. Tom Sawyer State Park
Lawson vs. Christian
November 17: Westin Bonaventure

Full Calendar of Women's Sports

MOST POPULAR ARTICLES & POSTS

The Beautiful Naked People
posted by MsAkiba

October 11, 2009 at 2:40pm

The Bizarre Life of Hope Solo Continues
posted by Sarah Hallett

November 14, 2012 at 3:03pm

Creating Stability in T & F Contracts
posted by amyYB

November 6, 2012 at 5:08pm

P.S. One's a Lesbian
posted by After Atalanta

October 26, 2011 at 11:23pm

Women vs. Men in Sports
posted by kristenbennett

April 11, 2011 at 1:08pm

More hot messes
posted by After Atalanta

November 16, 2012 at 8:18am


Liquid Web Fully Managed Web Hosting