This story demonstrates the power of the internet and the universality of sport and the Olympics. Th...more
posted 07/06/12 at 3:20pm
on Internet shows love for Sarah Robles, America's strongest woman
posted by After Atalanta
Wednesday, July 22, 2009 at 10:51am EDT
A blog focused on issues of gender and sport.
Support women's sports and SHARE this story with your friends!
Remember last year when sideline reporter Erin Andrews of ESPN was approached from behind by a collegiate football player who simulated a sexual maneuver as he was leaving the field? Well if you don't check it out here, along with my take on that situation and Andrews generally.
At that time, I noted that many people got angry at the people who spoke out against the harassment and that Andrews pretty much laughed it off in that awkward way one laughs off sexual harassment when you can't make a big deal out of it because, well, you're a woman in sports and you like your job. But I kind of knew this would not be the end of it. And I hate to say "I told you so" but...
A video of Andrews naked in a hotel room has appeared on the internet. An as-yet-unknown peeper took the video through a peep hole he/she drilled through a wall or door.
In no way am I saying the Andrews asked for it. But this is not surprising given that she has failed to speak up against the overt sexualization of her. It is possible that even if she had spoken out, the peeper still would have proceeded to film her. But it's too bad that this is the tipping point--a very extreme tipping point. Because no one is saying, as they did in the football player situation, that this is just funny or playful. But media outlets cover it by showing stills or blurred out portions of the video in their coverage of an event that they admit is an outrageous violation of privacy. Curious, eh?
No one can completely control their own image. Especially a woman, especially a woman in sports. I think this situation illustrates, though, that women like Andrews need to put more pressure on the media and the general public to respect her job skills and not just her looks.
And in a very generalized but interesting example of Canadian news media and American news media we have this article from the National Post and this one from the Washington Examiner. The latter talks very little about the event or the sexualization of Andrews but rather the double standard women who have never played a sport face in getting into broadcasting that sport (versus men who get broadcasting jobs without playing experience). The Canadian paper talks about the sexualization of women generally but how this event has everything to do with Andrews being a woman in sport. So nice to have a mainstream outlet make that point--so I don't have to! It also reminds us the Lisa Olson incident, which occurred over 20 years ago! Seems that the only thing that has changed is the technology.
Support women's sports and SHARE this story with your friends!
Today on the Women's Sports Calendar:
| Wimbledon Jun 25 - Jul 8: Centre Court | WNBA Games July 6: Allstate Arena |
MOST POPULAR ARTICLES & POSTS
May 5, 2012 at 12:54pm
July 2, 2012 at 11:43am
January 10, 2011 at 6:47pm
July 3, 2012 at 11:31am
October 7, 2009 at 3:14pm
April 4, 2012 at 10:03am
LATEST ARTICLES & POSTS
Thu at 4:17pm
Thu at 4:14pm
Thu at 3:08pm
Wed at 12:20am
There are 6 comments on this post. Join the discussion!
Well, the problem with Andrews, though, is that I suspect that being more vocal in opposition to attempts to sexualize her might affect her "likability," which plays a bigger role in sideline reporting than you think. An extreme case like this one allows her to be angry without alienating boorish male fans, but to those same fans, playfully laughing at "milder" sexual harassment helps to brand her as "easygoing" and less threatening to machismo. One wonders whether being viewed as "no nonsense" would hinder her ability to get athletes to open up to her.
As a fan who is less familiar with Erin Andrews, I have no idea whether her attractiveness is disarming, and allows athletes and coaches to be open and honest more readily than they would a broadcaster that they took more seriously. But I'd love to hear the perspectives of others.
Wednesday, July 22, 2009 at 2:24pm EDT
Check this out:
http://backporch.fanhouse.com/2009/07/22/everyone-deserves-blame-for-erin-andrews-video-fiasco/
Wednesday, July 22, 2009 at 5:08pm EDT
I do think she kind of calls it upon herself. She makes herself seem sexy and plays into the role, but as you stated, if you're a woman, in sports and like your job, you kind of have to go along with it. I don't really like her, but it could be perhaps because I'm jealous of her job. At the same time, she shouldn't have let it just keep going to that point. Very interesting about the video. She should have stood up for herself, but that doesn't mean the video wouldn't have been shot.
Wednesday, July 22, 2009 at 6:02pm EDT
Interesting post in the link above. I agree with the point the we all (=society) deserve blame for this incident...no one would make a video and put it on the internet if he/she didn't know everyone would flock to it like we shamelessly flock to every piece of celebrity controversy we hear about--from Britney Spears' wardrobe malfunctions to the Jon and Kate saga. Why are people like Heidi and Spencer so famous, even though they didn't do anything but provoke us with outrageous behavior? Because we can't get enough of it for some reason! We ask for them to come back again and again. So they get paid to go on a reality show and continue to act like imbeciles. And then they're on the next morning's talk shows.
NOW, please note that I'm not comparing Erin Andrews herself to Britney or Jon and Kate or Heidi and Spencer. BUT, the reason a nude video of her is such a big deal is because we first became obsessed with her looks and then slobbered like animals, wanting to push the limit more and more -- hey, that football player came up behind her and make a disgusting sexual gesture! Let's see what else can happen! Sure, the football player got in trouble, but everyone who enjoyed it on TV got off scot-free. Dignity needs to come back in style.
Wednesday, July 22, 2009 at 6:02pm EDT
Even still, there's no comparison between the Sexual Harassment that she has likely been subjected to in covering sports, and the violation of her privacy that happened. I think there's a HUGE difference between some random pervert secretly taping her because of her sexualization, and someone releasing the video into the world, so that everyone could see it. That seems motivated by malice. Worse still were the news outlets that helpfully showed edited clips or still pictures, amplifying the violation.
To me, this issue of sex and sports is very complicated, because of the role that sex plays in society. I think I'd prefer a system where female sexuality was viewed as just as empowering as male sexuality, and where objectification/exploitation was driven into the periphery. But what happens now, this "wink, wink" expression of sexiness, only serves to further fetishize women in male-dominated fields as "forbidden fruit," which ironically, drives things to a place where there's a MARKET for this type of malicious violation of personal integrity.
Wednesday, July 22, 2009 at 7:32pm EDT
It is very unfortunate that some think she "calls it upon herself." Sexual harassment of any kind is an unwelcome gesture, and no one -regardless of how much you don't like them- should be subject to it. Yes, she's supposed to be tough because she's in a profession where all eyes are on her- but that doesn't open up the playing field for a sexual-harassment free-for-all. We need to be careful at how we portray people in the media, especially women, and instead of objectifying them, allow them to have a voice. Right now, Erin probably doesn't feel like she has a voice, because if she stands up for herself, she's just a whiny girl that can't handle the male-dominated field she works in.
In my opinion, there are two violations of her privacy, both at the game and in the hotel. To demean this woman at a public venue (football game) and further catalyze the situation by distributing her (scabbed) naked video on the internet is disgusting and outrageous. We should never place the blame on her, she is entirely the victim here. By pushing the envelope and seeing just how far we can get 15minutes of fame in today's media continues to surprise me, and not in a good way.
Thursday, July 23, 2009 at 8:51am EDT